Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rob (c137)'s avatar

We are indeed upgrading. The past psychological experiments do not apply to current day humanity. https://robc137.substack.com/p/the-milgram-experiment-and-how-we

Actually, the claimed low life span of the past Hunter gatherers was wrong.

The average includes a higher baby mortality which drives the average down.

If they didn't count that mortality, the adults lived as long as we do today with all the tech we have today.

Easiest way to find the true life span is to use the median instead of the average. Averages put a lot of weight to the extreme lows and highs.

Expand full comment
Optiskeptic's avatar

Hi Dev - I had never encountered the term 'egregore' before this piece! You ask 'Are humans being controlled by egregores in some way?' I like the idea that egregores are clouds of shared similarities that in some way have agency - that seems to me to be very much how human communities work: I'm 'in' because I share enough of the 'community beliefs' not to alienate myself from the majority - in short, the egregore is defined by shared belief or, in your words 'a non-physical entity that represents the thinking behaviours of a group of people'. I can accept that as a manifesto, a ten commandments, a big book, a constitution. This means, to me, that the community has agency to define and change the parameters of the egregore. It seems like a paradox to suggest that the egregore itself has agency since in your description it is the consequence of the collective mindset of the community. On the other hand, if the egregore is the dictated words of an unaccountable supernatural entity then I'm out...

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts